Review fix pass 1 on the task 7 work; four findings, all closed.
1. The Qt demo's region sat across the middle of the window, which is exactly
where its own scripted input check pans: after the check's box zoom the press
opened DragMode::MoveRegion, the x range never moved, and the check printed
'input check pan FAIL' -- under an exit 0, because the verdict was printed and
not returned. The region now rides the left sixth (as the GLFW demo's does),
both checks pass, and the verdict is wired to the exit status. The same audit
found two more printed-only verdicts -- the GTK demo's scripted-resize layout
check and its screenshot write (and Qt's) -- now wired too. What stays
printed-only is the screenshot line of the GLFW host and the ImGui widget,
where the dump happens inside the adapter's frame loop.
2. A follow-ing link group was invisible to the input layer: a member's own axis
must be XFollow::Off (link_x() refuses a Live member), so Controller's
x_zoom_anchor() extrapolated a coordinate from the pointer instead of using
the live edge and a wheel over a row's axis strip walked the window back by
19% of its width (behind 0.000000 -> 0.285809 s). The group now publishes its
own edge to every member (Axis::live_owner + Plot::set_x_live_owner, written
by Figure::push_link, cleared when the group stops following or the row
unlinks), and x_zoom_anchor() reads it. Public-header addition, called out.
Measured after: behind 0.012992 s and the window's right edge bit-identical to
the edge the group published at the gesture.
3. The multiplot summary printed x_link_count() -- a number of groups -- under
'rows in it'. It now reports the members and the group count separately, and
every row line carries its own group id.
4. Host::controller_at() promised to clamp a pixel in a row gap to the nearest
row and only clamped below the last one, so a gap pixel went to row 0. It now
selects by distance, and tests/test_glfw_host.cpp pins it with a 40 px gap --
the first coverage of the host's figure routing, which needs no window.
New cases: tests/test_controller.cpp x2 (the anchor and the hint's lifecycle),
tests/test_glfw_host.cpp x3 (routing, the gap, the single-plot fallback): 229
cases, 0 failed, ASan clean. All five demos exit 0, the three self-checking
modes exit 0, and the amended assertions were confirmed failing against the
pre-fix behaviour.
Review of the atlas refactor found one Important and three Minor issues:
- Important: TextAtlas::sync called glGetIntegerv before any available() check,
so a host that synced before plot::gl::load() -- which is legal for a public
class Tasks 2 and 8 build backends on -- segfaulted on a null entry point
instead of receiving the Status the interface promises. It now follows the
handle-constructor convention (available(), then the entry point itself) and
reports Unsupported.
- empty() no longer means "a GL name exists": releasing one is a
glDeleteTextures call, so the no-atlas path forgets the atlas and only resets
the texture when there is a table to release it with.
- end_frame's comment still claimed the frame hands back the unpack alignment
init() set, contradicting the code below it and renderer.hpp.
- The orientation case's texel probe mapped the atlas' u along the cell's +v
axis and vice versa, which is a no-op for its two diagonal probes -- so it
could not fail on a transposed UV mapping, and its own comment misstated the
rule. Probes now follow the shader's rule and include an off-diagonal pair.
- The null-glyph path of add_text (and its twin in walk_text_clipped) was
unreached by any case.
Cases: text_atlas_reports_a_status_when_the_entry_points_are_missing,
add_text_skips_a_codepoint_the_backend_cannot_draw.
The text pipeline stages a glyph's rect *origin* per instance and carries the
rect's *size* once per draw, so a backend whose glyphs have differing rect sizes
-- a TrueType packing trimmed to ink, which is Task 8's shape -- would have drawn
every glyph at whichever size it happened to be told, with nothing downstream
able to tell. Make that constraint structural rather than documented:
- TextBackend::cell_uv() declares the one cell size, and the contract (an atlas
is a fixed-cell grid; a proportional face draws its glyphs *into* a uniform
cell instead of trimming each rect to its ink, and why the pipeline needs it)
is stated on the atlas accessors.
- glyph_is_cell() is the check; add_text()/set_cell() declare the cell from the
backend, and the staging path asserts it for every glyph in a debug build.
A release build draws on with the cell it was told, as before.
- Renderer::flush_text() takes u_glyph_uv from the backend, not from the batch,
so the draw's one rect size can never come from whichever glyph was staged
first.
Final whole-branch review fixes.
1 (Important). Plot::measurement() cached on (series pointer, sample count)
only, so a saturated StreamSeries -- whose size() stays pinned while x0()
advances every acquire() -- froze its readout on the first saturated frame
until a cursor moved. The cache key now carries the series' x0() (new
MeasureSlot::last_x0), so a sliding window recomputes and a static series
still does not: asserted with a new macro-gated counter hook
(plot/detail/measure_count.hpp, PLOT_COUNT_MEASURE_RECOMPUTES, wired like the
pyramid and ring counters, absent from the release library). New case
saturated_stream_measurement_tracks_the_sliding_window: saturated ring,
stationary cursors, ramp in absolute x -- zero recomputes for repeated reads
with nothing moving, one per acquire while it slides.
2-3, 9. Spec: 4.3 described a GL_LINE_STRIP path that does not exist (there is
one rasteriser -- instanced anti-aliased quads -- and dense_threshold_spp
selects the gather level, not a primitive); 8 named a PLOT_GL_CHECK() macro
that exists nowhere, and stated no exception policy. The table, the field's
comment and 8 now describe the real gather-level threshold, the real
glGetError() drain plus the stores' drop-to-orphan fallbacks, and the real
policy: library failures return Status/bool, allocating entry points propagate
std::bad_alloc.
4. The frame handed back neither GL_UNPACK_ALIGNMENT (init() sets 1 for the
atlas) nor the clear colour (queried once with a new glGetFloatv entry).
end_frame() restores both and renderer.hpp lists them in the residue
contract.
5. draw() kept a host TextBackend for layout while drawing with its own font.
The renderer now installs its font unconditionally -- strips and labels measure
and draw with one backend -- with a debug-build diagnostic if a different one
was set, and Plot::set_text_backend() is documented as the no-renderer path.
New case renderer_measures_the_labels_it_draws asserts layout, measuring and
the drawn label's ink agree.
6-10. draw()'s style overwrite stated at the call site; the load-sensitive
wall-clock bound in test_measure.cpp replaced by a counter assertion (same
interval, same fold count over a 512x length ratio); dump_frame_ppm drops
noexcept and says why it may allocate; error.txt ignored (not this project's,
not generated here) rather than deleted.
Verified: debug and release build clean (-Wall -Wextra -Wpedantic -Wconversion
-Wshadow), 4/4 ctest entries pass, 130 cases pass (was 127), umbrella and
header self-containment checks pass, and no counter symbol in the release
archive.
The linux-release preset inherited PLOT_BUILD_TESTS=ON, so the release build
compiled the pyramid cover/merge and ring upload/wait/slot counters into
libplot_core.a and cmake --install shipped them. Set PLOT_BUILD_TESTS=OFF in the
preset; the suite keeps running in linux-debug and linux-asan, which are
unchanged.
Also pin the two header properties the plan calls Global Constraints and that
nothing guarded: every header under include/plot/ compiles standalone, and
include/plot/plot.hpp includes every public one. tests/CMakeLists.txt globs the
headers at configure time (CONFIGURE_DEPENDS) and generates one TU per header
plus an umbrella TU that constructs Plot, Renderer, data::StreamSeries and
input::Controller; a ctest entry builds the header TUs and runs the umbrella,
and cmake/plot_umbrella_check.cmake fails configure and ctest when a public
header is missing from the umbrella.
The factor both the viewport and every forwarded input coordinate use came from
`gtk_widget_get_scale_factor()`, which GTK documents as "the next higher integer
value" under fractional scaling. It is now derived by `DeviceMapping::from_sizes()`
from the widget's logical allocation and the device size `GtkGLArea::resize`
reports -- the viewport that signal's default handler sets with
`glViewport(0, 0, w, h)` -- so the viewport, the renderer and input are one value
by construction. The public `int scale_factor()` became `f32 device_scale()`.
`kSurfacePixelsPerNotch` is now 100.0 and documented as a *calibration* with a
stated assumption, not a unit conversion attributed to axis_value120/Qt.
`::unrealize` releases the renderer unconditionally, after making the context
current: the error it used to check says nothing about whether GL names exist
(creation failure is the path that returns before a renderer is built), and
skipping the release left the deletes to the wrapper's destructor, with no
context.
The drag anchor caches its press point and offsets in logical pixels and scales
the difference by the factor in force now, so a scale change mid-drag cannot
become a phantom pan.
The demo stops its producer in `on_teardown`, before destroying the window whose
renderer the stream feeds.
The persistent-mapped instance ring had three slots and recorded a fence per
upload, so a frame recycled a slot whose fence was recorded a few draws earlier
*in that same frame*: from the fourth of the demos' nine uploads on, each one
waited on the frame's own work. It is free on a driver that retires draws
promptly (the GLFW host, 1.07 ms/frame) and ~4 ms of the Qt widget's 7.11 ms
under llvmpipe, and it grows with the trace and cursor counts this library
exists for.
* The ring grows to cover a frame's upload count, the frame's write cursor is
the ring index (so a frame writes 0, 1, 2, ... and never a slot twice), one
fence is recorded after the frame's last draw, and the only wait is at the
start of the next frame. A wait that times out, or a slot written with no
fence ever recorded behind it, drops the store to the orphan path -- the
treatment a refused fence already had -- so nothing is ever written into
storage the GPU may still be reading.
* New test-only counters (PLOT_RING_STATS, the PLOT_PYRAMID_COUNT_* pattern:
free functions, no member, so no consumer's layout changes) pin a frame's
upload and wait counts. The new tests assert the frame's slot offsets are
distinct, that the ring grew past its floor to cover the frame, and that a
frame waits at most once per store -- read from the counters and from
glClientWaitSync itself.
* qt6: print the unresolved entry-point names before the load-failure branch,
which used to return first and leave the one failure this widget can have
reporting nothing but a generic message.
* qt6: the cached pointer anchor is now in logical pixels and a move's delta is
the logical difference scaled by the DPR in effect, so a scale change between
two move events (the window dragged onto another monitor mid-drag) is no
longer a cross-scale jump applied as a pan. The anchor moved into a
toolkit-free unit (adapters/qt6/qt_pointer.hpp) with its own test.
GLFW demo headless: 1.07 -> 0.73 ms/frame. Qt widget under xvfb/llvmpipe:
7.1 -> 3.8 ms at dpr 1.0, 6.7 -> 3.6 ms at 1.25, with both upload paths still
rendering and the demo's scripted pan/box-zoom checks passing at both scales.
Zeroing an unusable wheel amount turned it into a zero-notch zoom: the factor was
exactly one, the range did not change, but the zoom body still ran through
set_x_range/set_y_range, which clear auto_scale unconditionally. One garbage wheel
therefore disarmed auto-fit on every axis. on_wheel now rejects an unusable amount
before the event can mutate anything, keeping the position fallback.
The tests that should have caught it are strengthened: the wheel case now asserts
auto scale is still armed (it was passing either way), and the invalid-position
case checks a pan measured from the last real position with the drag alive, rather
than a range nothing could have moved.
The widget drew a region derived from the child's content rect alone, so a child
the hosting window cut off cleared and painted over the host's pixels; it also
scaled ImGui's (-FLT_MAX, -FLT_MAX) no-pointer sentinel and differenced it against
the last real position, turning a drag out of the window into a ~1e35 pan, and it
forgot the host's button levels across a re-bind, handing the next plot a press
that never happened.
The region is now the content rect intersected with the child's clip rect (a
no-op when nothing clips it), an invalid position is no position update, and the
button levels survive a re-bind. The controller sanitises non-finite coordinates
and deltas for any host, and the widget's input translation now has a committed
test on the headless EGL context.
Findings from the review of the sliding-window change:
- A level >= 1 gather emitted only complete, wholly-retained buckets, so the
geometry stopped at the last bucket boundary inside the range: the newest
samples of a live window -- up to `span - 1` of them, about a pixel at the
level level_for() picks -- were not drawn, on the right edge, which is the
part of a scrolling trace that gets watched, and the oldest retained samples
fell outside the geometry too (the level-1 gather of a sliding window started
51 samples in). The two partial edge buckets are now gathered as raw samples
through copy_raw() and bracketed around the envelope -- the same exactness
split reduce/sum/sumsq already use -- so the emitted geometry spans the
requested range exactly. The pyramid still stores no partial bucket, so append
stays amortised O(1); at 1 MS/s the demo stages 511 extra sub-pixel segments
and still draws at 1.05 ms/frame, and the screenshot's trace now reaches one
column further at each end.
- `drop_before`'s doc claimed a no-op "for an empty pyramid": false, and
backwards -- the restart branch is exactly what an empty pyramid hits, which is
what StreamSeries::acquire() depends on when the ring saturated before the
first acquire. The precondition is `absolute_sample <= window_base()`, and the
restart is documented as what it is.
- The pyramid's memory figure was 3x optimistic: an entry is 24 bytes (MinMax
plus the exact sum/sumsq doubles), so level 0 costs 0.375n bytes and the whole
pyramid ~0.75n -- about 19% of 4-byte raw samples, not the 6% a min/max-only
index would cost. Corrected in the header, spec 4.2 and 4.5, with the trade
stated (the doubles buy O(log n) sum/mean/RMS/integral from whole buckets),
and the plan's Task 3 sketch no longer describes per-level prefix sums, a
level() span or an unaligned-end widening that does not exist.
Tests: `gather_at_a_lod_level_reaches_both_ends_of_the_window` pins that the
first and last emitted points are the oldest and newest retained samples -- with
spike values no bucket envelope can produce -- at level 1, at the level a dense
view picks, and for a static series whose end is unaligned. It fails against the
previous commit (first point at the first whole bucket), and so does the sliding
gather mapping check, which now accounts for the raw edge pairs.
Frame cost was O(capacity x levels) once the ring saturated: acquire() saw the
window base move (it always moves once the ring wraps), cleared the pyramid and
re-appended all 1,048,576 retained samples, and append() walked every live level
with no early stop -- 13,647,936 bucket merges and 73.8 ms per frame at a
1M-sample window, scaling with the window, which is what capped the 1 MS/s demo
at 32-58 ms/frame while it was still filling.
Index the pyramid in absolute bucket space instead. Level l bucket k covers the
samples [k * (kBucket << l), (k + 1) * (kBucket << l)), so a bucket's span never
depends on where the window starts and the window can slide over the aggregate
instead of forcing it to be rebuilt. Each level keeps its complete buckets in a
deque plus the absolute base of its first entry; append() folds a sample into the
single in-progress level-0 bucket and, only when that bucket completes, cascades
upward, stopping at the first level that gains no new entry; a new drop_before()
slides the window by discarding leading buckets and remembers where the window
begins. acquire() is now: drop to the new base, then append exactly what was
produced -- 256 merges and 0.034 ms per frame for 8192 new samples, independent
of the window, and memory bounded by the window (32,767 entries after 50M samples
through a 1M ring, the same as after 10M). A producer that laps the consumer by
more than capacity() between two acquires restarts the window rather than
splicing a gap.
Interface: `level(l) -> std::span<const MinMax>` cannot survive a ring and is
replaced by level_base/level_size/bucket in absolute bucket coordinates, plus
window_base/window_end/drop_before. The *_buckets queries stay in window
coordinates (index 0 = oldest retained sample), so Series keeps its window
semantics for callers; its exactness split now aligns in absolute space
(window_base() + the ceil/floor) because the bucket grid is absolute. The sums
move from per-level prefix sums to per-bucket ones -- the only representation a
sliding front can keep exact -- and StreamSeries::y_bounds() becomes
reduce(0, size()), exact in O(log n + kBucket) per frame instead of a scan of the
window. The pyramid owns the published window now, so there is no second copy of
base/end to keep in step, and gather() emits only buckets that are both complete
and wholly retained.
Tests: test-only merge counters (mirroring PLOT_PYRAMID_COUNT_COVERS, absent from
every non-test build) pin an acquire proportional to production and independent
of capacity, an append cost amortised over 16 live levels, and bounded memory;
brute-force checks pin absolute bucket aggregates across slides, sliding-window
reduce/sum/sumsq over unaligned ranges, and the level-1 gather mapping. The demo
now draws 946 samples/px at 1.03 ms/frame (967 fps) where the saturated window
cost 54.96 ms/frame (18 fps).
Two findings on the pass-1 fix:
- The reserved strips were clamped only to the viewport, so a title wider than a
narrow panel took the rest of it and the axes collapsed: draw_traces() returned
on a zero-width rect (no trace drawn, nothing reported) and a zero-height one
flattened every trace onto a single row. The chrome is now capped at half the
viewport -- the label strip is served first, the title strip takes what is left
of that allowance -- an over-long title is clipped to its strip by a walk that
both measures and stages it, and draw_traces() tests the height as well as the
width.
- Every titled y axis was staged at the same centred position inside one strip, so
a Left/Right pair of titles overprinted. Each titled axis now owns a text line:
the x strip grows one line per titled x axis (x_title_height), and the y runs
stack down the axes-tall strip, which needs no extra width for it.
Tests: `narrow_panel_with_a_long_y_title_still_draws` and
`short_panel_with_an_x_title_still_draws` pin the floor (the axes keeps half the
panel and the trace still covers the columns, with the title clipped into its
strip), `titled_axis_pairs_get_their_own_rows` pins one text row per titled axis
in both directions, and `layout_stacks_one_title_line_per_titled_axis` pins the
strip sizing. All fail against the pass-1 sources.
Four review findings on the Task 7 renderer:
- InstanceStore::epoch() is derived from gl::Buffer::generation() -- advanced by
every allocation, deletion and move -- plus the slot the instances were written
to, so the orphan fallback of grow_persistent() can no longer leave the vertex
array's attribute pointers bound to a deleted buffer: the epoch reports the new
identity and upload() re-points them before the draw.
- PlotLayout reserves y_title_area/x_title_area outside axes (sized from the text
metrics) and draw_titles() draws in them, so a title can no longer land on the
data, whatever the envelope does.
- draw() computes plot.layout() once and hands it to the helpers, instead of six
times per frame, each of which rebuilt the ticks and the grid.
- A refused fence is no longer dropped: mark_drawn() falls back to the orphan path
and reports the failure rather than rotating through an unsynchronised slot.
New smoke cases force both refusals through the GL entry points (glMapBufferRange,
glFenceSync) and assert the pixels plus the live transfer mode; the title case
asserts the title colour is absent from the bands inside axes and present in both
strips. All three fail against the pre-fix sources.
Every pixel-to-data conversion in the controller now maps through the
same rectangle Plot::x_transform/y_transform are built from:
- pan() derives the scale from layout().axes.w/.h, so a drag moves the
grabbed data point by exactly the drag distance (the viewport model
stranded it behind the pointer by the label-strip fraction).
- apply_box_zoom() clamps the selection to layout().axes and sets each
range from the transforms (x_transform().to_data_x(l/r), y_transform()
.to_data_y(bottom/top)); the selection's bottom edge is the y minimum.
- end_drag() takes the release event and refreshes the selection from its
coordinates before applying, so a host that reports only press and
release still frames the box instead of degrading it to a click.
- axis_zoom() uses a per-pixel sensitivity (200 px == one decade) rather
than reusing the wheel's per-notch constant, so a pixel drag is no
longer treated as a wheel notch.
Tests now assert the grab-and-drag invariant through the transform (the
old pixel-fraction assertions certified the viewport defect), add a
press+release-only box zoom, and pin the axis-zoom magnitude.
Martino Ferrari